The entire playoff committee needs to be drawn & disemboweled

Big Al Rogorson

Big Al Rogorson

Joined
Oct 15, 2021
Posts
3,766
Reaction score
1,179
Bookie:
$ 105,000.00
Strength of schedule means nothing. With Texas, Penn State, Indiana, & Notre Dame being ranked 3-6, that's a damn joke. Greg Sankey ought to get all his schools together, tell them they're gonna play their 8 conference games, then for the other 4, require them to schedule a Conference USA, a MAC, a FCS, & a Sunbelt. Don't risk a loss vs. a P4 team, as the conference schedule is a meat grinder & losses are gonna come to everyone.

Boise a top 4 seed?! What a freakin' disgrace. Same for mighty Miami.
 
Big Al Rogorson said:
Strength of schedule means nothing. With Texas, Penn State, Indiana, & Notre Dame being ranked 3-6, that's a damn joke. Greg Sankey ought to get all his schools together, tell them they're gonna play their 8 conference games, then for the other 4, require them to schedule a Conference USA, a MAC, a FCS, & a Sunbelt. Don't risk a loss vs. a P4 team, as the conference schedule is a meat grinder & losses are gonna come to everyone.

Boise a top 4 seed?! What a freakin' disgrace. Same for mighty Miami.
Click to expand...
You won't get an argument from me about that. That's been the consensus since the initial ratings this year. And you are right. The message they are sending is don't schedule many, if any, difficult OOC games. And get an easy conference schedule and we'll reward you for that.
 
I was preparing a nice piece of salmon for supper. I missed some of it. Did I hear someone say that the Ole Miss victory over Georgia is why they are ranked ahead of them? If so, should Tennessee be ranked ahead of Alabama? I could have heard all that wrong. Just curious.
 
And I know wins and all matters, but right now, Ole Miss, Alabama, and Georgia would push Miami's shit in.
 
Collegefbfan said:
I was preparing a nice piece of salmon for supper. I missed some of it. Did I hear someone say that the Ole Miss victory over Georgia is why they are ranked ahead of them? If so, should Tennessee be ranked ahead of Alabama? I could have heard all that wrong. Just curious.
Click to expand...
Yes they 100% should.
 
78Cyclones said:
And Georgia should be ranked ahead of Tennessee, and Alabama should be ranked ahead of Georgia, and round and round we go!
Click to expand...
Yup, I have no idea how to make any sense of it. I bet the CFP hopes some upsets happen.
 
The committee has always sucked ass. Nothing new.

It seems like a G5 getting the bye is going to happen relatively often with this structure and only four power conferences. Only takes one P4 conference to have a few teams beat each other up and the G5 can sneak in with a top 15 ranking.

They probably should just seed the top 4 by the rankings and then beyond that guarantee a home game for the conference champions that finish below 5.
 
Big Al Rogorson said:
Strength of schedule means nothing. With Texas, Penn State, Indiana, & Notre Dame being ranked 3-6, that's a damn joke. Greg Sankey ought to get all his schools together, tell them they're gonna play their 8 conference games, then for the other 4, require them to schedule a Conference USA, a MAC, a FCS, & a Sunbelt. Don't risk a loss vs. a P4 team, as the conference schedule is a meat grinder & losses are gonna come to everyone.

Boise a top 4 seed?! What a freakin' disgrace. Same for mighty Miami.
Click to expand...
What SOS metric are you using?
 
Eye test is preferred as 1st evaluation method for the committee.

SOS is considered later.
 
Cave_Johnson said:
The committee has always sucked ass. Nothing new.

It seems like a G5 getting the bye is going to happen relatively often with this structure and only four power conferences. Only takes one P4 conference to have a few teams beat each other up and the G5 can sneak in with a top 15 ranking.

They probably should just seed the top 4 by the rankings and then beyond that guarantee a home game for the conference champions that finish below 5.
Click to expand...

Acc and bigxii are not great leagues, so there will often be a g5 team better than one of their champs.

More telling will be the years there are 2 g5 teams better than the acc or bigxii champs and the acc/bigxii misses the playoffs entirely
 
Deep Creek said:
You won't get an argument from me about that. That's been the consensus since the initial ratings this year. And you are right. The message they are sending is don't schedule many, if any, difficult OOC games. And get an easy conference schedule and we'll reward you for that.
Click to expand...
Bingo!
Sgt Brutus said:
What SOS metric are you using?
Click to expand...
FPI
michaeljordan_fan said:
Eye test is preferred as 1st evaluation method for the committee.

SOS is considered later.
Click to expand...
Eye test & SOS are deeply linked. Watching Penn State give mighty Purdue the business compared to the slobber knocker between Alabama & South Carolina go down to the wire is like night & day football.
 
Big Al Rogorson said:
Bingo!

FPI

Eye test & SOS are deeply linked. Watching Penn State give mighty Purdue the business compared to the slobber knocker between Alabama & South Carolina go down to the wire is like night & day football.
Click to expand...
They aren't linked at all
 
Deep Creek said:
Who's crying dipshit. I have no reason to. My guys have won two frickin' games.

But we have Volunteers shaking in their boots.
Click to expand...
You're whining for the sake of whining.

Michigan's sos was bad last year. Eye test prevailed.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top