HooplaNation's 2023 CFB Week 9 Rankings - Discussion Thread

iowajerms

iowajerms

Joined
Sep 24, 2020
Posts
10,849
Reaction score
18,538
Bookie:
$ 3,475.00
Link to Voting Thread



https://hooplanation.com/threads/ho...ations-2023-cfb-week-2-rankings-top-25.22070/

Voting - HooplaNation's 2023 CFB Week 6 Rankings - Voting Thread

Link to Discussion Thread 1 Georgia 2 Texas 3 Ohio State 4 Washington 5 Florida State 6 Michigan 7 Oregon 8 Penn State 9 USC 10 Oklahoma 11 Miami FL 12 Notre Dame 13 Washington State 14 Alabama 15 North Carolina 16 Missouri 17 Kentucky 18 Maryland 19 Louisville 20 Air Force 21 Marshall 22 Ole...
hooplanation.com

HooplaNation's 2023 CFB Week 6 Rankings - Discussion Thread

Link to Voting Thread
hooplanation.com

Voting - HooplaNation's 2023 CFB Week 6 Rankings - Voting Thread

Link to Discussion Thread 1 Georgia 2 Michigan 3 Oklahoma 4 Washington 5 Ohio State 6 Oregon 7 Florida State 8 Penn State 9 USC 10 Louisville 11 North Carolina 12 Texas 13 Alabama 14 Oregon State 15 Washington State 16 Kentucky 17 Utah 18 Maryland 19 Air Force 20 Duke 21 Kansas 22 West Virginia...
hooplanation.com

HooplaNation's 2023 CFB Week 6 Rankings - Discussion Thread

Link to Voting Thread
hooplanation.com

Voting - HooplaNation's 2023 CFB Week 8 Rankings - Voting Thread

Link to Discussion Thread 1 Georgia 2 Washington 3 Michigan 4 Oklahoma 5 Ohio State 6 Penn State 7 Texas 8 Alabama 9 Florida State 10 Oregon 11 USC 12 Air Force 13 Missouri 14 Oregon State 15 Duke 16 Utah 17 Louisville 18 James Madison 19 Notre Dame 20 Ole Miss 21 Maryland 22 LSU 23 Fresno...
hooplanation.com

HooplaNation's 2023 CFB Week 8 Rankings - Discussion Thread

Link to Voting Thread
hooplanation.com
 
Crap, I forgot to add the 5-2 teams.

Oh well, I think all the teams I have, at least, deserve to be in "Others Receiving Votes" and teams like Tennessee and Duke will be ranked even though I don't have them.
 
1698075624676.png
 
Collegefbfan said:
1. Ohio State 0.99356
2. Florida State 0.99219
3. Oklahoma 0.99034
4. Michigan 0.98270
5. Washington 0.98106
6. Texas 0.97540
7. Georgia 0.96696
8. Oregon State 0.96410
9. Utah 0.96406
10. Alabama 0.96379
11. Ole Miss 0.96368
12. Penn State 0.95478
13. Missouri 0.95383
14. Oregon 0.94790
15. North Carolina 0.94738
16. Louisville 0.94480
17. James Madison 0.93586
18. Notre Dame 0.93372
19. LSU 0.92776
20. UCLA 0.92682
21. Kansas State 0.92675
22. Duke 0.92521
23. Iowa 0.92371
24. Wisconsin 0.92367
25. Tennessee 0.92353
Click to expand...
Is this the actual BCS computer rankings at the moment or do you have some sort of system?
 
Across The Field said:
Is this the actual BCS computer rankings at the moment or do you have some sort of system?
Click to expand...
He has a system. I've asked him before about it but can't remember how it works. Think the actual bcs would have Michigan Ohio State Georgia Florida State 1,2,3,4
 
fishinabarrel said:
He has a system. I've asked him before about it but can't remember how it works. Think the actual bcs would have Michigan Ohio State Georgia Florida State 1,2,3,4
Click to expand...
That's basically what I figured.
 
Deep Creek said:
As close as the games were, one would think Washington/Oregon and Oklahoma/Texas would be right next to each other in the rankings. Maybe I saw different games.
Click to expand...
Agreed, I like them being stacked in the 5-8 spots like in the AP. I'm still confused how Tennessee is ranked though.
 
Across The Field said:
Agreed, I like them being stacked in the 5-8 spots like in the AP. I'm still confused how Tennessee is ranked though.
Click to expand...

Tennessee is all over the map in terms of rankings:

Colley - 37
Sagarin - 14
Massey - 16
Wolfe - 36
Billingsley - 23
AP - 21
Coaches - 20

Averaging out the CPU's they are just outside the top 25. The human polls are largely keeping them ranked in this version of the BCS. I don't have them ranked either. No good wins, looked bad against UF. You could argue they are a top 25 team based on a power ranking standpoint, but if so it's barely. My guess is they lose to UK this weekend.
 
ericd7633 said:
Tennessee is all over the map in terms of rankings:

Colley - 37
Sagarin - 14
Massey - 16
Wolfe - 36
Billingsley - 23
AP - 21
Coaches - 20

Averaging out the CPU's they are just outside the top 25. The human polls are largely keeping them ranked in this version of the BCS. I don't have them ranked either. No good wins, looked bad against UF. You could argue they are a top 25 team based on a power ranking standpoint, but if so it's barely. My guess is they lose to UK this weekend.
Click to expand...
Holy hell Sagarin and Massey, how does that work? Did they just watch the first half vs Bama and then turn the channel and not look at box scores? I hope they lose to UK but that's not a good team either.
 
Across The Field said:
Is this the actual BCS computer rankings at the moment or do you have some sort of system?
Click to expand...
It includes win percentage so far out of playing 12 games. So, 12 possible wins (undefeated teams so far) out of 12 possible games of course is 100%, 9 wins (3 loss teams so far) out of 12 possible games is 75% and so on. It also includes an average (from different sites) of opponents' winning percentage and opponents' opponents' winning percentage where OW% is weighted a little more.

In relation to the BCS rankings, I think 1/3 or 2/3 was the AP poll and Coaches or something like that where voters are included. Mine does not include any voters.

I know it isn't perfect by any stretch, but I also feel that blue blood and helmet status don't factor in either. Basically, keep winning and playing at least a few "somebody's", and the team should be good. Also, something I just enjoy doing to see where they fall, and how close the teams are to the Hoopla rankings and others.
 
Last edited:
Deep Creek said:
As close as the games were, one would think Washington/Oregon and Oklahoma/Texas would be right next to each other in the rankings. Maybe I saw different games.
Click to expand...
If the other teams they faced are looked at Washington beat Oregon (6-1). Oregon's best win is who? Two teams that are 4-3. I know Washington looked like crap last week against whoever that was, but it was a win. Now, Oregon wins some of these tests coming up, they will rise of course.
 
Deep Creek said:
And why is Texas below Bama? Head to head matters............except when it doesn't?
Click to expand...

That's the one good thing about a committee. H2H will be applied when all is equal. CPU's can't distinguish that.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top