Ouch Big Ben

SJ76

SJ76

Joined
Aug 17, 2020
Posts
6,626
Reaction score
7,351
Bookie:
$ 22,597.00
Location
Titties, TX
Plus the Jags owned him with Bortles



 
Retire Ben.
 
phillyphilly said:
I can't believe people think he belongs in the HOF over Eli.
Click to expand...
30 more touchdowns and 43 less interceptions. Had far more winning seasons and playoff appearances. Career passer rating of 94 compared to Eli's 84.1, which was damn near the worst in the entire league during his time. I'm not sure how one makes an argument for Eli over Ben.
 
SU Nittany Tide said:
30 more touchdowns and 43 less interceptions. Had far more winning seasons and playoff appearances. Career passer rating of 94 compared to Eli's 84.1, which was damn near the worst in the entire league during his time. I'm not sure how one makes an argument for Eli over Ben.
Click to expand...
Eli was actually critical to the Giants’ Super Bowl wins (hence why he won two SB MVPs).
 
phillyphilly said:
Eli was actually critical to the Giants’ Super Bowl wins (hence why he won two SB MVPs).
Click to expand...
right, and outside those TWO seasons they played in the superbowl, he was as ho-hum as it gets when it comes to top-level quarterbacking. you'd have to be fucking pants-on-head shithouse crazy to think eli was better than ben. fuck outta here with that garbage.
 
ojb81 said:
right, and outside those TWO seasons they played in the superbowl, he was as ho-hum as it gets when it comes to top-level quarterbacking. you'd have to be fucking pants-on-head shithouse crazy to think eli was better than ben. fuck outta here with that garbage.
Click to expand...
Ben was not good during his two SB wins. So what that he compiled a bunch of stats? Eli will forever be better. I’m not saying that Eli is all that great. Ben is tremendously overrated.
 
Screenshot_20210111-180335_Samsung Internet.jpg
 
SU Nittany Tide said:
30 more touchdowns and 43 less interceptions. Had far more winning seasons and playoff appearances. Career passer rating of 94 compared to Eli's 84.1, which was damn near the worst in the entire league during his time. I'm not sure how one makes an argument for Eli over Ben.
Click to expand...
Pretty easy if you’re not trying to make an argument for either of them.

That said, I think Ben gets in. And I’m fine with it. And, I think Eli gets it, which I’m less cool with. It will always be for only two throws in his career.
 
Orlando_Eagles said:
Pretty easy if you’re not trying to make an argument for either of them.

That said, I think Ben gets in. And I’m fine with it. And, I think Eli gets it, which I’m less cool with. It will always be for only two throws in his career.
Click to expand...
David Tyree should get credit for one of those.
 
moxie said:
David Tyree should get credit for one of those.
Click to expand...
Oh absolutely. In almost the same way that Manningham should get the credit for the other one.
 
We should totally trademark the almost HoF
 
phillyphilly said:
Ben was not good during his two SB wins. So what that he compiled a bunch of stats? Eli will forever be better. I’m not saying that Eli is all that great. Ben is tremendously overrated.
Click to expand...
"compile a bunch of stats"??? bwahahahah good God
 
phillyphilly said:
Ben was not good during his two SB wins. So what that he compiled a bunch of stats? Eli will forever be better. I’m not saying that Eli is all that great. Ben is tremendously overrated.
Click to expand...
Eli has a career passer rating that was only considered good 20 years before he began playing.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top