Most iconic moment from each team

Illustrious Potentate

Illustrious Potentate

Joined
Aug 17, 2020
Posts
41,844
Reaction score
50,547
Bookie:
$ 10,650.00
Some have a few moments hard to pick between, others I can’t really think of any.

Braves- Aaron passes Ruth
Marlins- Bartman
Nationals- Kendrick grand slam
Mets- Buckner
Phillies- Tug McGraw closing it out in 80

Pirates- Maz game 7 walk off homer
Reds- Rose passes Cobb
Cubs- Ending the 108 year drought
Cardinals- 2011 game 6 comeback
Brewers- Braun game 162 homer to put Brewers in playoffs???

Rockies- Holiday still hasn’t touched home
Diamondbacks- 2001 game 7 Gonzalez walk off flair off Rivera
Giants- The Willie Mays over the shoulder catch
Dodgers- Jackie Robinson breaks color barrier
Padres- I really don’t know. Tony Gwynn’s 3000th hit???

Yankees- a lot to choose from, first that came to mind was Babe’s called shot, so that’s what I’m going with
Red Sox- Ending the curse of the Bambino
Blue Jays- Touch em all Joe
Rays- Longoria’s walkoff to complete the comeback for a WC spot in 2011
Orioles- Ripken passes Gehrig

Royals- The blown call in game 6 in 85
White Sox- Podsednik World Series Homer???
Twins- Jack Morris 91 game 7 performance
Tigers- Ordonez 2006 ALCS walk off???
Guardians- Feller’s opening day no hitter

Mariners- Griffey Sr and Jr go back to back????
A’s- Moneyball assisted, but the Hatteburg homer
Angels- Spezio game 6 homer in 2002
Rangers- Kenny Rogers perfect game
Astros- Altuve ALCS homer off Chapman
 
Yankees-losing to the Marlins in the 2003 World Series
Red Sox- Game 6 of the 1986 World Series
Dodgers-2021 NLCS
Mets- Second half of 2007 season
 
Illustrious Potentate said:
Some have a few moments hard to pick between, others I can’t really think of any.

Braves- Aaron passes Ruth
Marlins- Bartman
Nationals- Kendrick grand slam
Mets- Buckner
Phillies- Tug McGraw closing it out in 80

Pirates- Maz game 7 walk off homer
Reds- Rose passes Cobb
Cubs- Ending the 108 year drought
Cardinals- 2011 game 6 comeback
Brewers- Braun game 162 homer to put Brewers in playoffs???

Rockies- Holiday still hasn’t touched home
Diamondbacks- 2001 game 7 Gonzalez walk off flair off Rivera
Giants- The Willie Mays over the shoulder catch
Dodgers- Jackie Robinson breaks color barrier
Padres- I really don’t know. Tony Gwynn’s 3000th hit???

Yankees- a lot to choose from, first that came to mind was Babe’s called shot, so that’s what I’m going with
Red Sox- Ending the curse of the Bambino
Blue Jays- Touch em all Joe
Rays- Longoria’s walkoff to complete the comeback for a WC spot in 2011
Orioles- Ripken passes Gehrig

Royals- The blown call in game 6 in 85
White Sox- Podsednik World Series Homer???
Twins- Jack Morris 91 game 7 performance
Tigers- Ordonez 2006 ALCS walk off???
Guardians- Feller’s opening day no hitter

Mariners- Griffey Sr and Jr go back to back????
A’s- Moneyball assisted, but the Hatteburg homer
Angels- Spezio game 6 homer in 2002
Rangers- Kenny Rogers perfect game
Astros- Altuve ALCS homer off Chapman
Click to expand...
Old school Oakland A's fan, but this is pobably the biggest play since it was in World Series versus the Big Red Machine and Series went 7. Joe Rudi catch.

 
Illustrious Potentate said:
Some have a few moments hard to pick between, others I can’t really think of any.

Braves- Aaron passes Ruth
Marlins- Bartman
Nationals- Kendrick grand slam
Mets- Buckner
Phillies- Tug McGraw closing it out in 80

Pirates- Maz game 7 walk off homer
Reds- Rose passes Cobb
Cubs- Ending the 108 year drought
Cardinals- 2011 game 6 comeback
Brewers- Braun game 162 homer to put Brewers in playoffs???

Rockies- Holiday still hasn’t touched home
Diamondbacks- 2001 game 7 Gonzalez walk off flair off Rivera
Giants- The Willie Mays over the shoulder catch
Dodgers- Jackie Robinson breaks color barrier
Padres- I really don’t know. Tony Gwynn’s 3000th hit???

Yankees- a lot to choose from, first that came to mind was Babe’s called shot, so that’s what I’m going with
Red Sox- Ending the curse of the Bambino
Blue Jays- Touch em all Joe
Rays- Longoria’s walkoff to complete the comeback for a WC spot in 2011
Orioles- Ripken passes Gehrig

Royals- The blown call in game 6 in 85
White Sox- Podsednik World Series Homer???
Twins- Jack Morris 91 game 7 performance
Tigers- Ordonez 2006 ALCS walk off???
Guardians- Feller’s opening day no hitter

Mariners- Griffey Sr and Jr go back to back????
A’s- Moneyball assisted, but the Hatteburg homer
Angels- Spezio game 6 homer in 2002
Rangers- Kenny Rogers perfect game
Astros- Altuve ALCS homer off Chapman
Click to expand...
Dodgers-Gibson's homer off Eckersley, '88 World Series game 1
Padres-Garvey's homer to win NLCS game 4, 1984
Tigers-Gibson's homer off Gossage, '84 World Series game 5, after Gossage refused to give him a free pass that the manager suggested
Rangers-Ryan's 7th no-hitter
 
Big Al Rogorson said:
Dodgers-Gibson's homer off Eckersley, '88 World Series game 1
Padres-Garvey's homer to win NLCS game 4, 1984
Tigers-Gibson's homer off Gossage, '84 World Series game 5, after Gossage refused to give him a free pass that the manager suggested
Rangers-Ryan's 7th no-hitter
Click to expand...
I agree on the Eckerskey homer. Gut punch for A’s fans.
 
For the White Sox, I'd say the 1919 World Series i.e. the Black Sox.
For the Giants, I'd argue Bobby Thomson's "Shot hear 'round the world"
For the Rays, Game 4 of the 2020 WS, Phillips hit to CF and two Dodger errors let them score2 and win
 
rsw626 said:
For the White Sox, I'd say the 1919 World Series i.e. the Black Sox.
For the Giants, I'd argue Bobby Thomson's "Shot hear 'round the world"
For the Rays, Game 4 of the 2020 WS, Phillips hit to CF and two Dodger errors let them score2 and win
Click to expand...
I consider the Black Sox to be more than a moment.

I’d say more people today know about the Mays catch than The Shot Heard Around the World.

I’ll take your word on the Rays, but it’s hard for me to say anything from 2020 is gonna be any team’s most iconic moment
 
Illustrious Potentate said:
Some have a few moments hard to pick between, others I can’t really think of any.

Braves- Aaron passes Ruth
Marlins- Bartman
Nationals- Kendrick grand slam
Mets- Buckner
Phillies- Tug McGraw closing it out in 80

Pirates- Maz game 7 walk off homer
Reds- Rose passes Cobb
Cubs- Ending the 108 year drought
Cardinals- 2011 game 6 comeback
Brewers- Braun game 162 homer to put Brewers in playoffs???

Rockies- Holiday still hasn’t touched home
Diamondbacks- 2001 game 7 Gonzalez walk off flair off Rivera
Giants- The Willie Mays over the shoulder catch
Dodgers- Jackie Robinson breaks color barrier
Padres- I really don’t know. Tony Gwynn’s 3000th hit???

Yankees- a lot to choose from, first that came to mind was Babe’s called shot, so that’s what I’m going with
Red Sox- Ending the curse of the Bambino
Blue Jays- Touch em all Joe
Rays- Longoria’s walkoff to complete the comeback for a WC spot in 2011
Orioles- Ripken passes Gehrig

Royals- The blown call in game 6 in 85
White Sox- Podsednik World Series Homer???
Twins- Jack Morris 91 game 7 performance
Tigers- Ordonez 2006 ALCS walk off???
Guardians- Feller’s opening day no hitter

Mariners- Griffey Sr and Jr go back to back????
A’s- Moneyball assisted, but the Hatteburg homer
Angels- Spezio game 6 homer in 2002
Rangers- Kenny Rogers perfect game
Astros- Altuve ALCS homer off Chapman
Click to expand...
Good list. Good choice for the Cards. Hard to choose on the Cards though, so many iconic moments. Lots of championships and that's what champions do.
 
Illustrious Potentate said:
I consider the Black Sox to be more than a moment.

I’d say more people today know about the Mays catch than The Shot Heard Around the World.

I’ll take your word on the Rays, but it’s hard for me to say anything from 2020 is gonna be any team’s most iconic moment
Click to expand...

With all of the attention that's been given to illegal sign stealing lately I'm surprised that Thomson's HR doesn't get brought up more often.
 
DragonFromTo said:
With all of the attention that's been given to illegal sign stealing lately I'm surprised that Thomson's HR doesn't get brought up more often.
Click to expand...
I haven’t heard the background, were the Giants stealing signs? If so, good on them for doing anything they could to keep the Dodgers out of the WS.

But I consider the Thompson homer about the same as the Fisk homer. Was really not all that significant since in both cases, the team lost the WS. And I always thought the Thompson homer was so famous because of the radio call that went with it
 
Illustrious Potentate said:
I haven’t heard the background, were the Giants stealing signs? If so, good on them for doing anything they could to keep the Dodgers out of the WS.

But I consider the Thompson homer about the same as the Fisk homer. Was really not all that significant since in both cases, the team lost the WS. And I always thought the Thompson homer was so famous because of the radio call that went with it
Click to expand...

The HR is certainly a memorable moment anyway, I wasn't mentioning the sign stealing to take away from that. Just surprised that it wasn't mentioned more during the recent mess. Telescope out behind center field.

The Echoing Green — Joshua Prager

www.joshuaprager.com www.joshuaprager.com
 
Illustrious Potentate said:
I consider the Black Sox to be more than a moment.

I’d say more people today know about the Mays catch than The Shot Heard Around the World.

I’ll take your word on the Rays, but it’s hard for me to say anything from 2020 is gonna be any team’s most iconic moment
Click to expand...
It was cool for them, and to see the Dodgers make two errors on one play.

I can see your point on the White Sox, but it still looms over them.
 
Could the Giants be Madison Bumgartner Game 7 epic relief appearance versus Royals in Game 7 2014 World Series?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top