Top 5 Quarterbacks All Time

I'm going to rank my top 5 by which QB I'd personally want on my team the most. I'm only including QBs that's I've actually watched play, so 1985 and later. I'm also taking into account the different rules from different decades, so stats aren't everything.

1 - Aaron Rodgers
2 - Joe Montana
3 - Peyton Manning
4 - Dan Marino
5 - Tom Brady

HMs - Steve Young, Brett Favre
 
PackJason said:
I'm obviously biased being a life-long Packers fan, but I agree. Rodgers is the best QB I've ever watched play.
Click to expand...
Rodgers is Top 10. I'm a Packers fan and owner, but I don't think he's better than Brady and some others. In my lifetime, Peyton Manning and Montana were significantly more clutch and intelligent than Rodgers. Likewise, people putting Brett Favre so high -- the guy was a good, not great leader, and had an awful tendency (all his career) to launch the ball upwards, whenever he was in trouble. Most sacks all-time, but also most picks.
PackJason said:
I'm not one to judge QBs just by how many Superbowls they have won because football is the ultimate team sport. To the people who do rank QBs by Superbowls, do you honestly think Trent Dilfer was a better QB than Dan Marino?
Click to expand...
No one thinks this. Dilfer was "good enough", like Eli Manning was good enough, for his teams, at the time. The Super Bowl is impossible with just one player, or usually, even with just the offense. Regular season performance matters, as well as getting a decently long set of data, to evaluate greatness.
 
1.Brady.....The guys track record speaks for itself....And to take another team at 42(?) to a Champupnship game.....Does anyone think Winston would have the Bucs in the Championship game.....?
And I believe the Bucs beat GB....

2. Montana......guy was just clutch

3.Manning

4.Brees

5.Rodgers or Favre.....Hate Rodgers with a passion,but the guy can play,qont lie......

5.Soon to be Mahomes.....Dont see nothing stopping him.....

And I wont include the oldtimers.....Started watching football in 75 and never seen them play.........
But Id take the guys I mentioned over Marino,Staubach,Bradshaw and Young.....
 
Wood20ks said:
1.Brady.....The guys track record speaks for itself....And to take another team at 42(?) to a Champupnship game.....Does anyone think Winston would have the Bucs in the Championship game.....?
And I believe the Bucs beat GB....

2. Montana......guy was just clutch

3.Manning

4.Brees

5.Rodgers or Favre.....Hate Rodgers with a passion,but the guy can play,qont lie......

5.Soon to be Mahomes.....Dont see nothing stopping him.....

And I wont include the oldtimers.....Started watching football in 75 and never seen them play.........
But Id take the guys I mentioned over Marino,Staubach,Bradshaw and Young.....
Click to expand...
Basically my take as well (y)
 
someone needs to put Ryan Leaf up there
 
Cave_Johnson said:
Anyway, I didn't start really watching the NFL until the late 90s, but Peyton and Rodgers are the best I've seen.

Mahomes could have the title when all is said and done though. Dude is unreal sometimes.
Click to expand...
LOL @ the reactionary bullshit of these clowns not even listing Peyton Manning in their top 5. :pound:
 
HammerDown said:
1. Peyton manning
2. Steve McNair
3. Troy Aikman
4. Drew Bledsoe
5. Tom Tupa
Click to expand...
Tom Brady Flirt GIF
 
1. Tom Brady
2. Joe Montana
3. Johnny Unitas
4. Patrick Mahomes
5. Peyton Manning
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top