I want chaos next week

NewPhoneWhoDis said:
They won't have an extra win, because they already have the two losses and the two losses were BAD. One to a terrible team and the other getting absolutely blown out.

So all the win would do is give them the same amount of wins as the other teams you mentioned.
Click to expand...
Ya they will, they’ll be 11-2 which is an “extra win over a few teams ahead of them“ (Ole Miss and Ohio State at 10-2).

Who is the committee putting in if the above scenario happened?
 
ralphiewvu said:
It is very very unlikely it happens, but Oregon isn’t totally out of it yet. If Bama, Michigan, Cincy and junior all lose and assuming Oregon beats Utah Oregon at 10 would jet up quite possibly to the top 4 with that conference champ on its resume. It’s not over for them to get into this but it’s very very unlikely.
Click to expand...

Pass me whatever you are smoking
 
ralphiewvu said:
Ya they will, they’ll be 11-2 which is an “extra win over a few teams ahead of them“ (Ole Miss and Ohio State at 10-2).

Who is the committee putting in if the above scenario happened?
Click to expand...
Ole Miss and OSU have ZERO chance to get in. Not sure why you are even bringing them up. Michigan 1 loss, Okie State 1 loss, ND 1 loss, Cincy 0 loss, Georgia 0 loss, Alabama 1 loss. That's 6 teams right there. Which one is Oregon getting in over with a loss to 3 win Stanford and a 28 point loss to Utah?
 
NewPhoneWhoDis said:
Ole Miss and OSU have ZERO chance to get in. Not sure why you are even bringing them up. Michigan 1 loss, Okie State 1 loss, ND 1 loss, Cincy 0 loss, Georgia 0 loss, Alabama 1 loss. That's 6 teams right there. Which one is Oregon getting in over with a loss to 3 win Stanford and a 28 point loss to Utah?
Click to expand...
They are currently ahead of Oregon in the AP and coaches poll, that’s why I mentioned them.

Are you being deliberately obtuse or don’t you get it? Try 2 loss Michigan, 2 loss Junior, 1 loss Cincy, and 2 loss bama. My scenario for Oregon getting in is if all these teams lose this weekend. Who the hell is the committee putting in if the scenario I have stated continually happens?
 
Here is your issue. All 3 of those teams would have MUCH BETTER losses than Oregon and the exact same record. Oregon was absolutely dominated by Utah and they lost to frickin' Stanford. The only ranked team Oregon played in the PAC was #23 Utah and they lost 38-7. So they aren't going to have anywhere near the amount good wins to push them past teams with 2 losses.

So you can play scenario village all you'd like, but you and I have as much chance of getting into the CFP as Oregon does.
 
NewPhoneWhoDis said:
Here is your issue. All 3 of those teams would have MUCH BETTER losses than Oregon and the exact same record. Oregon was absolutely dominated by Utah and they lost to frickin' Stanford. The only ranked team Oregon played in the PAC was #23 Utah and they lost 38-7. So they aren't going to have anywhere near the amount good wins to push them past teams with 2 losses.

So you can play scenario village all you'd like, but you and I have as much chance of getting into the CFP as Oregon does.
Click to expand...

Again I ask, who is the committee putting in if the scenario happens?

Oregon would have a conference championship and not be a team with the most recent loss. Its a very unlikely chance but it’s still a chance. They also have one of the best wins of the season. It’s a small chance but still a chance.
 
I want Kirk Frerentz to be at Iowa FOREVER.
 
ralphiewvu said:
Again I ask, who is the committee putting in if the scenario happens?

Oregon would have a conference championship and not be a team with the most recent loss. Its a very unlikely chance but it’s still a chance. They also have one of the best wins of the season. It’s a small chance but still a chance.
Click to expand...
I will break it down for you, since you must not follow CFB too closely:

Big 12 -- Okie State/Baylor: Okie State wins, they'd get in over Oregon. Baylor wins, they'd get in over Oregon. So t ake your pick (this is IF the Big 12 even has a representative.

SEC -- Georgia/Alabama: Georgia could stay home and still go to the CFP. Alabama could lose to Georgia and STILL get in over Oregon because they would have WAY BETTER losses, a much tougher schedule and the same record.

Notre Dame -- ND has 1 loss to Cincy. They also just curb stomped Stanford, who beat Oregon. So not only would have they a better record, a WAY BETTER loss, and they pummeled the common opponent they have with Oregon, while Oregon lost.

Cincy -- They'd have a better record, a better win (beating ND at ND) and since ND would get in over Oregon, Cincy won the H2H with ND, so they'd get in over ND.

B1G -- Michigan/Iowa -- If Michigan lost -- they'd have losses to top 10 MSU and top 15 Iowa, so better losses and the same big win, but UM's was more dominant and at the end of the year, where OSU was LIGHT YEARS better, as Tre'veon Henderson became the starter and Stroud had experience under his belt at QB. The other common opponent is Washington, who Oregon fought tooth and nail, while Michigan hammered Washington by 3 tds while rushing for 350 yards on them.

So now you tell me how Oregon is going to get in and why?
 
NewPhoneWhoDis said:
I will break it down for you, since you must not follow CFB too closely:

Big 12 -- Okie State/Baylor: Okie State wins, they'd get in over Oregon. Baylor wins, they'd get in over Oregon. So t ake your pick (this is IF the Big 12 even has a representative.

SEC -- Georgia/Alabama: Georgia could stay home and still go to the CFP. Alabama could lose to Georgia and STILL get in over Oregon because they would have WAY BETTER losses, a much tougher schedule and the same record.

Notre Dame -- ND has 1 loss to Cincy. They also just curb stomped Stanford, who beat Oregon. So not only would have they a better record, a WAY BETTER loss, and they pummeled the common opponent they have with Oregon, while Oregon lost.

Cincy -- They'd have a better record, a better win (beating ND at ND) and since ND would get in over Oregon, Cincy won the H2H with ND, so they'd get in over ND.

B1G -- Michigan/Iowa -- If Michigan lost -- they'd have losses to top 10 MSU and top 15 Iowa, so better losses and the same big win, but UM's was more dominant and at the end of the year, where OSU was LIGHT YEARS better, as Tre'veon Henderson became the starter and Stroud had experience under his belt at QB. The other common opponent is Washington, who Oregon fought tooth and nail, while Michigan hammered Washington by 3 tds while rushing for 350 yards on them.

So now you tell me how Oregon is going to get in and why?
Click to expand...
In my scenario:

1)Georgia
2)ND
3)Oregon
4)Baylor

Oregons resume is far better then Baylor’s, they get in over them.

If Alabama gets crushed by Georgia they won’t put them in. Considering how they’ve looked even when winning recently.

NDs in

They aren’t putting in a 1 loss non conference champ G5. Won’t happen. Cincy would be out.

Michigan is an interesting debate but Oregon would have a conference championship from a P5 league to add to its belt while Michigan would have a more recent loss. Seeing you debate this on here leads me to believe you put zero stock in winning a conference championship is important, which is stupid.
 
ralphiewvu said:
In my scenario:

1)Georgia
2)ND
3)Oregon
4)Baylor

Oregons resume is far better then Baylor’s, they get in over them.

If Alabama gets crushed by Georgia they won’t put them in. Considering how they’ve looked even when winning recently.

NDs in

They aren’t putting in a 1 loss non conference champ G5. Won’t happen. Cincy would be out.

Michigan is an interesting debate but Oregon would have a conference championship from a P5 league to add to its belt while Michigan would have a more recent loss. Seeing you debate this on here leads me to believe you put zero stock in winning a conference championship is important, which is stupid.
Click to expand...
When the conference consists of exactly one team ranked all year and one added after beating the only ranked team -- yes, I don't put much stock in a PAC conference championship. As I said -- Oregon will have played exactly ONE team who was ranked in all their conference games. Utah.
 
NewPhoneWhoDis said:
When the conference consists of exactly one team ranked all year and one added after beating the only ranked team -- yes, I don't put much stock in a PAC conference championship. As I said -- Oregon will have played exactly ONE team who was ranked in all their conference games. Utah.
Click to expand...
They still would win it in this scenario (conference champ game). Also all Those teams (in the scenario that lose) would have a more recent loss. Again it’s unlikely to happen but if those teams lose Oregon absolutely has a shot to make it in.
 
ralphiewvu said:
In my scenario:

1)Georgia
2)ND
3)Oregon
4)Baylor

Oregons resume is far better then Baylor’s, they get in over them.

If Alabama gets crushed by Georgia they won’t put them in. Considering how they’ve looked even when winning recently.

NDs in

They aren’t putting in a 1 loss non conference champ G5. Won’t happen. Cincy would be out.

Michigan is an interesting debate but Oregon would have a conference championship from a P5 league to add to its belt while Michigan would have a more recent loss. Seeing you debate this on here leads me to believe youIn put zero stock in winning a conference championship is important, which is stupid.
Click to expand...
In a normal year they aren't putting 1 loss G5 team in, but when that G5 team went on the road and beat ND by 10 points, there is zero chance they put ND in over Cincy. And there is no chance Oregon gets in over ND.

And if you are talking about how a team has looked winning -- take a look at Oregon's schedule and the games they've struggled in. They struggled with 4-7 Cal, they struggled with 4-7 Washington, they lost to 3-8 Stanford, just to name a few.

You can put any number of chaos scenarios in and none of them will have Oregon getting in
 
ralphiewvu said:
They still would win it in this scenario (conference champ game). Also all Those teams (in the scenario that lose) would have a more recent loss. Again it’s unlikely to happen but if those teams lose Oregon absolutely has a shot to make it in.
Click to expand...
They take the year, as a whole, and take the 4 best teams. There isn't a scenario in the world where Oregon will be one of the 4 best teams. None.
 
NewPhoneWhoDis said:
In a normal year they aren't putting 1 loss G5 team in, but when that G5 team went on the road and beat ND by 10 points, there is zero chance they put ND in over Cincy. And there is no chance Oregon gets in over ND.

And if you are talking about how a team has looked winning -- take a look at Oregon's schedule and the games they've struggled in. They struggled with 4-7 Cal, they struggled with 4-7 Washington, they lost to 3-8 Stanford, just to name a few.

You can put any number of chaos scenarios in and none of them will have Oregon getting in
Click to expand...
They aren’t going to put in a 1 loss G5 team that didn’t even win their conference in ANY YEAR.

I agree ND gets in before Oregon.

Teams struggle, Alabama has struggled recently, Ohio State a short stint of struggle earlier. Teams struggle. Oregon’s not the only one.

Oregon has a shot, they need a lot to happen and it’s unlikely but it’s still a shot.
 
NewPhoneWhoDis said:
They take the year, as a whole, and take the 4 best teams. There isn't a scenario in the world where Oregon will be one of the 4 best teams. None.
Click to expand...
What makes someone one of the best teams? At some point you have to use resumes and not just eye test who one of the 4 best is.
 
ralphiewvu said:
What makes someone one of the best teams? At some point you have to use resumes and not just eye test who one of the 4 best is.
Click to expand...
The reason why Oregon will never get in. They have two of the worst losses of any team within a whisper of the CFP. Name me a loss worse than Stanford for any team you are mentioning as top 4? Name me a loss worse than losing by 31 to Utah?

NO CHANCE.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top