Reunion Baseball Draft : CHAT

Derek Jeter over Bob Gibson, Tony Gwynn, Jimmie Foxx, Warren Spahn, Tris Speaker and Sandy Koufax....my 11 year old could have done a better job
 
Satchell over Nolan Ryan, Lefty Grove, Warren Spahn, Bob Feller, Steve Carlton, Clayton Kershaw???

I get it, he was great, no doubt but he threw more than 150 innings once and only over 100 innings like 6 times. Using this logic Bo Jackson should be #1?
 
I did text Femur
 
I'll compare it to the one I found on bestegg, I don't really like either but I feel bestegg was a little better. There's a myriad of issues with both lists. Neither is great, but you'd expect an entity like ESPN's to be better, and I can't really say that it is. (Bold is a player not on both lists, and parenthesis are the difference in position between the lists)

100. Barry Larkin - Roy Halladay (-8)
99. Phil Niekro - Joey Votto (N/A)
98. Jim Thome - Barry Larkin (+2)
97. Adrian Beltre - Willie McCovey (-24)
96. Charlie Gehringer - Roberto Alomar (-10)
95. Duke Snider - Tony Gwynn (-51)
94. Bryce Harper - Lou Boudreau (N/A)
93. John Smoltz - Harry Heilmann (N/A)
92. Roy Halladay - Nolan Ryan (-50)
91. Ryne Sandberg - Home Run Baker (N/A
90. Ivan Rodriguez - Justin Verlander (-18)
89. Shoeless Joe Jackson - Clayton Kershaw (-37)
88. Willie Stargell - Sal Bando (N/A)
87. Carlton Fisk - Fergie Jenkins (N/A)
86. Roberto Alomar - Carlos Beltran (N/A)
85. Jim Palmer - Mike Mussina (N/A)
84. Paul Molitor - Derek Jeter (-54)
83. Roy Campanella - Tim Raines (N/A)
82. Eddie Collins - Todd Helton (N/A)
81. Mike Piazza - Luke Appling (N/A)
80. Robin Yount - Ryne Sandberg (+11)
79. Hank Greenberg - Andre Dawson (N/A)
78. Chipper Jones - Curt Schilling (N/A)
77. Vladimir Guerrero - Miguel Cabrera (-18)
76. Cap Anson - Alan Trammell (N/A)
75. Rod Carew - Kenny Lofton (N/A)
74. Juan Marichal - Ozzie Smith (-5)
73. Willie McCovey - Ichiro Suzuki (-27)
72. Justin Verlander - Christy Mathewson (-47)
71. Al Kaline - Larry Walker (N/A)
70. Harmon Killebrew - Pee Wee Reese (N/A)
69. Ozzie Smith - Gary Carter (N/A)
68. Manny Ramirez - Duke Snider (+27)
67. Brooks Robinson. - Chase Utley (N/A)
66. Cal Ripken Jr. - Robin Roberts (N/A)
65. Max Scherzer - Bobby Grich (N/A)
64. Eddie Mathews - Reggie Jackson (-9)
63. David Ortiz - Johnny Bench (-34)
62. Mel Ott - Steve Carlton (-4)
61. Carl Yastrzemski - Frank Thomas (-12)
60. Whitey Ford - Hank Greenberg (+19)
59. Miguel Cabrera - Brooks Robinson (+8)
58. Steve Carlton - Arky Vaughan (N/A)
57. Pete Alexander - Bert Blyleven (N/A)
56. Dave Winfield - Warren Spahn (-9)
55. Reggie Jackson - Pete Rose (-21)
54. Lefty Grove - Chipper Jones (+24)
53. Oscar Charleston - Robin Yount (+27)
52. Clayton Kershaw - Nap Lajoie (-4)
51. Ernie Banks - Johnny Mize (N/A)
50. Bob Feller - Ernie Banks (+1)
49. Frank Thomas - Ron Santo (N/A)
48. Nap Lajoie - Rod Carew (+27)
47. Warren Spahn - Charlie Gehringer (+49)
46. Ichiro Suzuki - Jeff Bagwell (N/A)
45. Wade Boggs - Adrian Beltre (+52)
44. Tony Gwynn - Jackie Robinson (-6)
43. George Brett- Al Kaline (+28)
42. Nolan Ryan - George Brett (+1)
41. Satchel Paige - Eddie Mathews (+23)
40. Jimmie Foxx - Phil Niekro (+59)
39. Yogi Berra - Jimmie Foxx (+1)
38. Jackie Robinson - Honus Wagner (-26)
37. Joe Morgan - Alex Rodriguez (-11)
36. Tris Speaker - Roberto Clemente (-9)
35. Josh Gibson - Cy Young (-14)
34. Pete Rose - Mike Trout (-19)
33. Bob Gibson - Bob Gibson (-)
32. Sandy Koufax - Cal Ripken, Jr. (+34)
31. Mariano Rivera - Ken Griffey, Jr. (-18)
30. Albert Pujols - Mel Ott (+32)
29. Johnny Bench - Wade Boggs (+16)
28. Derek Jeter - Pedro Martinez (-17)
27. Roberto Clemente - Roger Clemens (-10)
26. Alex Rodriguez - Pete Alexander (+31)
25. Christy Mathewson - Joe DiMaggio (-9)
24. Randy Johnson - Bob Feller (+26)
23. Rickey Henderson - Frank Robinson (-4)
22. Tom Seaver - Carl Yastrzemski (+39)
21. Cy Young - Albert Pujols (+9)
20. Rogers Hornsby - Mike Schmidt (-2)
19. Frank Robinson - Rickey Henderson (+4)
18. Mike Schmidt - Eddie Collins (+64)
17. Roger Clemens - Lefty Grove (+37)
16. Joe DiMaggio - Randy Johnson (+8)
15. Mike Trout - Lou Gehrig (-9)
14. Greg Maddux - Tris Speaker (+22)
13. Ken Griffey Jr. - Tom Seaver (+9)
12. Honus Wagner - Greg Maddux (+2)
11. Pedro Martinez - Mickey Mantle (-4)
10. Stan Musial - Rogers Hornsby (+10)
9. Walter Johnson - Joe Morgan (+28)
8. Barry Bonds - Stan Musial (+2)
7. Mickey Mantle - Ty Cobb (-3)
6. Lou Gehrig - Walter Johnson (+3)
5. Ted Williams - Hank Aaron (-2)
4. Ty Cobb - Barry Bonds (+3)
3. Hank Aaron - Ted Williams (+2)
2. Willie Mays - Willie Mays (-)
1. Babe Ruth - Babe Ruth (-)
 
Nosferatu said:
Joe Morgan over Mickey lmao
Click to expand...

Hell, I thought omitting Koufax off the list completely was an even bigger issue to the second list than that - but yeah - it's hard to take too many of these lists seriously.
 
Clemente and Jeter at 27 & 28 —way too high especially Jeter.
Bonds at 7 lol

A lot of misses
 
No lineup change. But if you could switch Bunning and Guidry in my rotation, that’d be cool.
 
So we just doing regular voting?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top