1935 - 1985 MLB Bucket & Cap Draft QF4 : Shane vs Sushi

Nosferatu

Nosferatu

Joined
Aug 17, 2020
Posts
10,442
Reaction score
11,826
Bookie:
$ 241,091.00
Location
Texas
SHANE

LINEUP
1. Paul Molitor (R) - 3B - $7 - 3
2. Richie Ashburn (L) - CF - $5 - 1
3. Hank Aaron (R) - RF - $21 - 4
4. Carl Yastrzemski (L) - LF - $18 - 2
5. Ernie Banks (R) - SS - $11 - 5
6. Gil Hodges (R) - 1B - $8 - 6
7. Yogi Berra (L) - C - $15 - 1
8. Tony Oliva (L) - DH - $8 - 6
9. Davey Johnson (R) - 2B - $4 - 6

ROTATION
1. Bob Gibson (R) - $8 - 3
2. Gaylord Perry (R) - $5 - 5
3. Bert Blyleven (R) - $2 - 2
4. Sam McDowell (L) - $6 - 3
5. J.R. Richard (R) - $1 - 2

BULLPEN
John Hiller (L) - $1 - 1
Bobby Shantz (L) - $3 - 5
Craig Lefferts (L) - $0 - 4
Andy McGaffigan (R) - $0 - 4

VS

SUSHI

LINEUP
1. Joe Morgan (L) - 2B - $10 - 3
2. Bill Madlock (R) - 3B - $3 - 2
3. Willie McCovey (L) - 1B - $6 - 4
4. Roy Campanella (R) - C - $8 - 5
5. Billy Williams (L) - LF - $6 - 5
6. Jose Canseco (R) - DH - $6 - 5
7. Reggie Jackson (L) - RF/DH - $14 - 1
8. Tony Fernandez (B) - SS - $5 - 5
9. Gary Pettis (B) - CF - $0 - 1

ROTATION
1. Tom Seaver (R) - $12 - 6
2. Bob Feller (R) - $8 - 3
3. Robin Roberts (R) - $7 - 1
4. Billy Pierce (L) - $7 - 2
5. Harry Brecheen (L) - $2 - 3

BULLPEN
Sparky Lyle (L) - $3 - 2
Jeff Reardon (R) - $4 - 4
Gene Garber (R) - $0 - 4
Steve Mingori (L) - $0 - 6
 
Last edited:
Shane - 4
Sushi - 5
 
Last edited:
Shane
 
Sushi.
 
Sushi
 
Okay, I may have spoken too soon, this one is real close. I like Sushi's pen more, I probably like Shane's rotation a little more but damn that's close. Nobody likes Hodges more than I do. Honestly I don't know. I feel bad voting against one of them...

I guess i'll go Shane. I have never felt worse for voting against someone because this one is seriously too close to call.
 
Sushi needs Smitty and UK to vote for him. Either of them vote Shane, Shane moves on.

Shane $3 (Great job by the way)
Sushi $25
 
Nosferatu said:
Sushi needs Smitty and UK to vote for him. Either of them vote Shane, Shane moves on.

Shane $3 (Great job by the way)
Sushi $25
Click to expand...

How does that math work on me needing two votes and Shane only needs one? I see the voting as 4-4. Am I taking crazy pills?
 
citysushi said:
How does that math work on me needing two votes and Shane only needs one? I see the voting as 4-4. Am I taking crazy pills?
Click to expand...


Ties are decided by remaining $$$ If both end up with 5 votes he has less money remaining so he wins.
 
Sushi
 
Nosferatu said:
Ties are decided by remaining $$$ If both end up with 5 votes he has less money remaining so he wins.
Click to expand...

Got it.

But shouldn't the tie go to the person who spent less? I mean if terms of drafting, my team has 22 less all-star appearances than he does.
 
citysushi said:
Got it.

But shouldn't the tie go to the person who spent less? I mean if terms of drafting, my team has 22 less all-star appearances than he does.
Click to expand...


I guess it could but IMO having less remaining money means you handled the restriction better or played the game better.
 
Nosferatu said:
I guess it could but IMO having less remaining money means you handled the restriction better or played the game better.
Click to expand...
That’s fair. He drafted better within the constraints. But also if I win I’m gonna let him know his salary cap ain’t shit. Lol
 
Smitty is out golfing when he gets home he will decide this.
 
Nosferatu said:
Okay, I may have spoken too soon, this one is real close. I like Sushi's pen more, I probably like Shane's rotation a little more but damn that's close. Nobody likes Hodges more than I do. Honestly I don't know. I feel bad voting against one of them...

I guess i'll go Shane. I have never felt worse for voting against someone because this one is seriously too close to call.
Click to expand...
Pen goes to Sushi. Rotation somewhat even but maybe it’s just me…my lineup is better and I don’t consider it close. Still overall pretty close. Sushi had a damn good team
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top