HooplaNation's Week 5 Rankings - Discussion Thread

UbetterDUCK said:
Baylor is ranked but BYU isn’t? :headscratch:
Click to expand...

Both are 3-1. Baylor’s loss was a nail-biter. BYU’s loss consisted of them basically getting run over.

Plus H2H is overrated imo. Especially when, ya know, the home team wins by one score in OT.
 
Deep Creek said:
That one is a head scratcher to me as well.
Click to expand...

I looked and I was one of the culprits guilty of it as well :facepalm: . I will fix next week.

Too many 4-0 teams right now and I wanted to give love to some of those 4-0 teams like FSU and Syracuse so I forgot to include Baylor.
 
Volbound1700 said:
I looked and I was one of the culprits guilty of it as well :facepalm: . I will fix next week.

Too many 4-0 teams right now and I wanted to give love to some of those 4-0 teams like FSU and Syracuse so I forgot to include Baylor.
Click to expand...
That’s okay as long as BYU is ahead of them…at least imo. I’m a believer in what is settled on the field head to head…at least until the losses add up. Then they can drop like a turd in a punch bowl for all I care.
 
Deep Creek said:
That’s okay as long as BYU is ahead of them…at least imo. I’m a believer in what is settled on the field head to head…at least until the losses add up. Then they can drop like a turd in a punch bowl for all I care.
Click to expand...

You don't understand, I have Baylor at #22 and BYU not listed at all. So I am as guilty as anyone with regard to Baylor/BYU situation.
 
Ibagree
Knight&Day said:
Both are 3-1. Baylor’s loss was a nail-biter. BYU’s loss consisted of them basically getting run over.

Plus H2H is overrated imo. Especially when, ya know, the home team wins by one score in OT.
Click to expand...

I agree H2H can be overlooked in situations as the season plays out. In this case, however, it's a bit premature as it has only been 2 weeks and they have the same number of losses and BYUs is a to a higher ranked team.

I do believe Baylor is the better team and the rankings will show that as the season goes on
 
fishinabarrel said:
Ibagree


I agree H2H can be overlooked in situations as the season plays out. In this case, however, it's a bit premature as it has only been 2 weeks and they have the same number of losses and BYUs is a to a higher ranked team.

I do believe Baylor is the better team and the rankings will show that as the season goes on
Click to expand...

I still feel like there is a lot of chaos in the rankings in general. I had 28 or more teams that I wanted to rank and I had to figure it out. I wanted to keep Baylor ranked and totally forgot about BYU. However, who do I kick out for BYU? Most of the teams that I added were 4-0 teams. I think more games still need to be played before we figure out how to rank everyone appropriately.
 
Hell, I just rank #1-8, throw the rest in a hat and pick them out randomly. Well, somewhat randomly...
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top