Poll If you had to pick…

Who you got?

  • Total voters
    29
Illustrious Potentate

Illustrious Potentate

Joined
Aug 17, 2020
Posts
41,828
Reaction score
50,531
Bookie:
$ 10,650.00
Let’s say there’s more chaos this week that opens the door up for one of the three loss SEC teams to make the playoffs.

Which one of Bama, Ole Miss and South Carolina would you say is the most deserving?

Personally, I’d pick South Carolina. They were screwed by the refs against LSU, and they don’t have losses to bad teams like Kentucky, Oklahoma and Vanderbilt. They’d also have some solid wins against A&M, Missouri and Clemson. So even though their two legit losses are against the other two teams in consideration, I’d take them.

I can see the Ole Miss argument since they didn’t have any blowout losses like the other two choices and their win against UGA is the most impressive win of the teams, but Kentucky was a terrible loss and it happened at home

I don’t think Bama has a real case other than marketability and tv ratings

I didn’t include A&M because if they finish with three losses, it means they won the conference and are definitely in
 
I’d go Ole Miss because I think they’d be a tougher matchup and have better QB play than the others.

Alabama doesn’t even have a QB, they have a dang good RB pretending to be QB.
 
Most deserving? Carolina. Based on 125 years of futility.
CoalTrain said:
I’d go Ole Miss because I think they’d be a tougher matchup and have better QB play than the others.
Click to expand...
:slaphappy:

Sellers has improved so much during this season. I'm just hoping he has the weapons next year. He's a good mobile QB who is tough to bring down, and his decision-making has gotten so much better with playing time. Of course he's a Freshman and not as experienced as Dart, but I think he's gonna be a good one for Carolina.
 
Ultimately, I had to vote for Ole Miss. They clobbered Carolina in W-B. Bama squeaked by the Gamecocks at home.

Both Ole Miss and Bama have bad losses, so the only thing that really separates them is the common opponents thing.
 
CoalTrain said:
I’d go Ole Miss because I think they’d be a tougher matchup and have better QB play than the others.

Alabama doesn’t even have a QB, they have a dang good RB pretending to be QB.
Click to expand...
Decent chance Ole Miss is the last one standing with 3 losses after this weekend anyways.
 
Hu War Yu said:
Ultimately, I had to vote for Ole Miss. They clobbered Carolina in W-B. Bama squeaked by the Gamecocks at home.

Both Ole Miss and Bama have bad losses, so the only thing that really separates them is the common opponents thing.
Click to expand...
The committee doesn’t take it into account, but I do, as far as I’m concerned, SCar is really a two loss team after that hose job against LSU. If they lose that game straight up, I’d probably lean Ole Miss too
 
Illustrious Potentate said:
Let’s say there’s more chaos this week that opens the door up for one of the three loss SEC teams to make the playoffs.

Which one of Bama, Ole Miss and South Carolina would you say is the most deserving?

Personally, I’d pick South Carolina. They were screwed by the refs against LSU, and they don’t have losses to bad teams like Kentucky, Oklahoma and Vanderbilt. They’d also have some solid wins against A&M, Missouri and Clemson. So even though their two legit losses are against the other two teams in consideration, I’d take them.

I can see the Ole Miss argument since they didn’t have any blowout losses like the other two choices and their win against UGA is the most impressive win of the teams, but Kentucky was a terrible loss and it happened at home

I don’t think Bama has a real case other than marketability and tv ratings

I didn’t include A&M because if they finish with three losses, it means they won the conference and are definitely in
Click to expand...
This. and also because fuck Bama.
 
Gotta go Ole Piss....

Mainly because of Jaxson Dart.
 
osubuckeye89 said:
Pointless, it's going to be Alabama without question if they have to take one.
Click to expand...
Probably.

Ole Miss screwed themselves badly on Saturday and if South Carolina had a kicker they would be much better shape.

All that being said if SC can beat Clemson the they have the best opportunity to impress the committee. Alabama plays Auburn at home and Ole Miss plays state who is winless in the SEC.
 
Wild Turkey said:
Probably.

Ole Miss screwed themselves badly on Saturday and if South Carolina had a kicker they would be much better shape.

All that being said if SC can beat Clemson the they have the best opportunity to impress the committee. Alabama plays Auburn at home and Ole Miss plays state who is winless in the SEC.
Click to expand...

Bama will probably beat Auburn by like 24 and we will get the predictable "Alabama proves they belong in the playoff still with dominance of Auburn" headlines.
 
osubuckeye89 said:
Bama will probably beat Auburn by like 24 and we will get the predictable "Alabama proves they belong in the playoff still with dominance of Auburn" headlines.
Click to expand...
Bama can go to the Tidy Bowl.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top