Nah, we are top tier. Not beating one team isn't what Top Tier means.
You will note that your team is the only one that I commented on. I had you top tier for the reasons you mention, and I had a asterisk by your name as being one of the Big 8 that will drive the TV money in 2 years. I have no objection to someone saying you should be in the top tier. The reason I had you in the top of the next tier down is because, as I noted, you guys are natty or bust.
In the 11 years you reference, you have a 14-0 with a NC due to a generational player 11 years ago, then a 12-2 8 years ago. In the other 9 years you have lost 48 games, or a little over 5 losses per year. You lost 9 games 2 years after the natty, and the year before you played for it again. Sorry, but that isn't top tier to me.
You aren't UTjr, and I put you in the Big 8 of the SEC - AU, UA, UGA, LSU, UF, TAMU, UT, and OU. But your inconsistency doesn't compare with the other teams I have in the Top Tier.