Scenario: Conf Champ v. H2H

[ELTEXAN]

Scenario:
ALPHA team from p5 conference beats BRAVO team from a different p5 conference in week 3.

ALPHA team goes undefeated to the CCG, but loses to a #12 ranked two-loss team and ends up 12-1.

BRAVO team goes undefeated the rest of the way and wins their conference ending up 12-1.

The final CFP spot is between these two teams.

Let’s say all other factors are about equal.
Which team should go, ALPHA or BRAVO?

In your head, what takes precedence:
Head to Head win? or Conference Title Holder?

 

[Red_Alert]

 

[fishinabarrel]

Scenario:
ALPHA team from p5 conference beats BRAVO team from a different p5 conference in week 3.

ALPHA team goes undefeated to the CCG, but loses to a #12 ranked two-loss team and ends up 12-1.

BRAVO team goes undefeated the rest of the way and wins their conference ending up 12-1.

The final CFP spot is between these two teams.

Let’s say all other factors are about equal.
Which team should go, ALPHA or BRAVO?

In your head, what takes precedence:
Head to Head win? or Conference Title Holder?

Need to know SOS of both teams as well before I make a decision.

Edit:nevermind. Saw you said other factors are about equal. Would probably lean towards the conference champ unless the game in week 3 was a complete blowout

 

[WhosYourDawggy]

Scenario:
ALPHA team from p5 conference beats BRAVO team from a different p5 conference in week 3.

ALPHA team goes undefeated to the CCG, but loses to a #12 ranked two-loss team and ends up 12-1.

BRAVO team goes undefeated the rest of the way and wins their conference ending up 12-1.

The final CFP spot is between these two teams.

Let’s say all other factors are about equal.
Which team should go, ALPHA or BRAVO?

In your head, what takes precedence:
Head to Head win? or Conference Title Holder?

I would vote for expansion to 12 teams so stupid issues like these don’t come up.

 

[Wishbone]

Sorry Alabama is still in.

 

[78Cyclones]

If Texas and Alabama both only have one loss, Texas should get the nod.

 

[ELTEXAN]

If Texas and Alabama both only have one loss, Texas should get the nod.

That's not the scenario here.

 

[Red_Alert]

That's not the scenario here.

It's not the "the scenario" anywhere.

This is OD level scenario village.

 

[duckboy33]

If Texas and Alabama both only have one loss, Texas should get the nod.

If the committee has to choose between 12-1 Alabama and 12-1 Texas it will be fascinating IMO.

Alabama will have won a better conference and will have a better team in the power ratings world. But Texas beat them by double digits in their house. I think the committee will pick Alabama and then anger will ensue.