At first, a lot of SEC fans were opposed but this move solves several headaches. I still say Texas is probably the biggest winner in this move and I will explain why below. Texas A&M, however, may not lose very much and may come out a winner in this move as well.
1. Restoring rivalries. What you effectively get is a lot of rivalries restored if the division is split East and West as proposed. The East would be mostly made up of "original" SEC Schools. Only LSU, Ole Miss, and Miss State are left in the West from the original cast and all three don't necessarily have major rivalries with anyone in the East. Alabama vs. LSU might be the lone example of a lost rivalry but it was more of a recent than historical rivalry. LSU's two biggest, end of year, rivals in Arkansas and Texas A&M are retained in the West. The Mississippi schools will be fine as long as they retain their fight against each other.
2. Texas and Texas A&M win big. Both struggled in the Big12 partially due to the over abundance of other Texas teams and lack of major matchups. Now there is only one matchup in Texas that will matter every year. Texas vs Texas A&M will become a lot like the Alabama-Auburn rivalry. There is no other Texas team in the region to compete. All of the other Texas teams will LOSE BIG as these two programs will define the state. There is enough room for both to be competitive and I don't see the Aggies going away any time soon with will benefit not just A&M but Texas as well.
Texas wins bigger than anyone. They dump the other Texas teams that competed with them for recruits and embarrassed them with defeats. They restore the game with A&M, keep Oklahoma game, restore an annual rivalry with Arkansas, and gain a rivalry game with LSU. Not to mention the possibility of games against top teams in the other division. You push out some of the smaller schools and gain big-time and historical rivalries. The SEC West is a good fit for creating new rivalries. LSU vs. Oklahoma, Arkansas vs. Oklahoma, Arkansas vs. Texas, Arkansas vs. Texas A&M, Arkansas vs. Missouri, Ole Miss vs. Missouri, etc. These games are just a good fit.
3. Money - Let's be honest this is the main reason for this move. The SEC now has the following all-time greatest CFB programs:
1. Alabama - The article has OU as #1 but I don't see how Alabama isn't #1
2. Oklahoma
7. Texas
10. Tennessee
11. LSU
12. Georgia
13. Auburn
15. Florida - They should be higher IMO
19. Arkansas
23. Texas A&M
24. Ole Miss
The AP poll is has been the most consistent ranking system over the long history of college football. What programs come out best? Here are the top programs according to a CFN formula using all the…
collegefootballnews.com
Granted some of these programs are interchangeable but it shows you the slew of power teams that are in the league now.
4. Division Balance - I think the chance for Balance is still strong. The West loses its titan Alabama but Oklahoma is a titan. Sure, Oklahoma will need to shore up their defense but I have confidence they will start to recruit SEC talent and be a legit contender very soon. It won't be hard for Texas to rebound either. Arkansas looks like it is on the upswing, LSU is two years removed from a National Title, Texas A&M finished #4 in rankings last season and is bringing in tons of talent, the Mississippi schools have interesting coaches that have schemes that are very familiar to the Big12 newcomers.