Trubissky vs Mayfield who’s better

[SJ76]

Trubisky's game turned around after the top 3 corners on the team went out. He still had to be the one to capitalize, which he gets full credit for, but a bad defense losing most of it's corners is a situation where most QB's could win.

point is he got it done. With less talent and weapons around him than Baker. It’s not like either have been tearing it up. Hence the potato salad option

 

[Meebs]

point is he got it done. With less talent and weapons around him than Baker. It’s not like either have been tearing it up. Hence the potato salad option

No question, he gets the credit.

 

[SJ76]

No question, he gets the credit.

Week 2 will probably be different. But if Joey Burreaux goes off and beats the Browns? And he’s from Ohio you know... Browns fans switch? Lol

 

[night]

I don’t think either are worth writing home about.

 

[The Derski]

It’s a toss up at this point. People keep talking about Trubs overthrowing guys but I saw some horrific throws by Baker yesterday. OBJ with no one 20 yards of him and Baker airmailed it to the cheerleaders. OBJ is hating life right now. On and off the field.

 

[Kburjr]

It’s a toss up at this point. People keep talking about Trubs overthrowing guys but I saw some horrific throws by Baker yesterday. OBJ with no one 20 yards of him and Baker airmailed it to the cheerleaders. OBJ is hating life right now. On and off the field.

I saw the GOAT airmail a few yesterday. Shit happens.

 

[SJ76]

I saw the GOAT airmail a few yesterday. Shit happens.

Is Favre back? Nice

 

[Mcnabb7542]

trubisky breaks out this year.

You meant that "breaking out" right?

 

[Top Cat]

lol

 

[ChiSoxFan]

I'm going with the homer Trubisky choice on this one.

 

[ChiSoxFan]

Mayfield is better at Progressive insurance commercials.

 

[Kevin12773]

 

[Balljim55]

Making grand statements because a crappy QB has one good quarter tends to come back and bite you in the ass.
Baker looked very good last knight

 

[Shanemansj13]

Trubs with 3 TDs in the 4th quarter so far


Baker thinking Cheesecake Factory

Both aren't franchise QB's as of right now and both are inconsistent. I still think Baker throws a better ball, Mitch is a much better dual-threat guy. As of right now, both aren't leading their teams to deep in the playoffs. Mitch does have a much better defenses though and Allen Robinson ain't bad. Both aren't great decision makers...imo

 

[DJ Fieri]

Trubisky's game turned around after the top 3 corners on the team went out. He still had to be the one to capitalize, which he gets full credit for, but a bad defense losing most of it's corners is a situation where most QB's could win.

BOOM.

 

[CaptainStubing]

neither. they are equally meh.

 

[stakesarehigh]

Both aren't franchise QB's as of right now and both are inconsistent. I still think Baker throws a better ball, Mitch is a much better dual-threat guy. As of right now, both aren't leading their teams to deep in the playoffs. Mitch does have a much better defenses though and Allen Robinson ain't bad. Both aren't great decision makers...imo

The bears have two decent rbs. They are not chubb and Hunt but they arent store brand rbs either.

Obviously I'd take bakers weapons though

 

[SJ76]

Both aren't franchise QB's as of right now and both are inconsistent. I still think Baker throws a better ball, Mitch is a much better dual-threat guy. As of right now, both aren't leading their teams to deep in the playoffs. Mitch does have a much better defenses though and Allen Robinson ain't bad. Both aren't great decision makers...imo

That is a solid non-homer response. If I’m judging which one has more “he ain’t that good” in him I’m going Trubs. But we will see what he does here in week 2. Trubs was a reach by the Bears from day 1. I laughed and laughed watching the Texans get D Watson.

 

[SJ76]

Making grand statements because a crappy QB has one good quarter tends to come back and bite you in the ass.
Baker looked very good last knight

He should look good after his shitty week 1. So whose Defense is better? Bengals or Detroit?

Trubs had a great quarter and led his team to a W. Was against mop up DBs? Perhaps

This question in OP is a pillow fight. I have no dog in this fight just an interesting question for 2 franchises

 

[Top Cat]

neither. they are equally meh.

Mayfield is a playable tier 3 starter. Trubisky is a backup QB LARPing as a starting QB. Mayfield may be frustrating, but mediocre is much better than awful, imo.