Poll HooplaNation Poll Tourney - Best Team Since 1997 Season - Seeding Thread

Which would you say are the six best on this list?

  • Total voters
    9
  • Poll closed .
iowajerms

iowajerms

Joined
Sep 24, 2020
Posts
10,851
Reaction score
18,543
Bookie:
$ 3,475.00
Since I messed up in the last thread, there will be one more elimination to make, but this poll will be to determine the seeds of the 16 team tournament.

Seeding Criteria
1) # of votes in this thread
2) Auto In > Bubble Team
3a) Auto In Tie Breaker - # of votes in first thread
3b) Bubble Team Tie Breaker - # of votes in all threads
4) The team with the larger point differential in their season+post season.

Teams that have made it
Bold teams = Auto In teams (10 teams that finished in top of first set of filter threads)

1997 Nebraska
1997 Michigan
1998 Tennessee
1999 Florida State
2001 Miami (FL)
2002 Ohio State
2004 USC
2005 Texas
2008 Florida
2009 Alabama
2011 LSU
2013 Florida State
2018 Clemson
2019 LSU
2020 Alabama
2021 Georgia - I messed up in last thread poll and didn't include them, so they became an additional bubble team.
2022 Georgia

Here is the blank bracket
In the tourney, better seed wins tie breaker and winner of first matchup automatically wins rematch.

Untitled1.jpg
 
Last edited:
Pretty difficult to come up with just 6. Most of them had pretty good balance.
For criteria I went with "Undefeated" and highest rankings in the 4 categories.
SRS = Simple Rating System a rating that takes into account average point differential and strength of schedule. The rating is denominated in points above/below average, where zero is average, although it should be noted that margin of victory has been assigned a lower bound of 7 points and an upper bound of 24 points. Non-major opponents are included as a single team in the ratings.
'Undefeated' teams that I eliminated and why.
1997 Nebraska (SOS 41st)
1997 Michigan (Pts/G (48th) (SOS 32nd)
1998 Tennessee (Pts/G 19th) (SOS 26th)
2002 Ohio St (Pts/G 41st)
2005 Texas (SOS 23rd)
2013 Florida St (SOS 59th)
2019 LSU (Opp Pts/G (32nd)

1997 Nebraska (13-0)
Pts/G: 46.7 (1st)
Opp Pts/G: 16.5 (12th)
SRS: 2nd
SOS: 41st

1997 Michigan (12-0)
Pts/G: 26.8 (48th)
Opp Pts/G: 9.5 (1st)
SRS: 5th
SOS: 32nd

1998 Tennessee (13-0)
Pts/G: 33.2 (19th)
Opp Pts/G: 14.5 (8th)
SRS: 3rd
SOS: 26th

1999 Florida St (12-0)
Pts/G: 38.2 (3rd)
Opp Pts/G: 16.9 (11th)
SRS: 1st
SOS: 13th

2001 Miami, FL (12-0)
Pts/G: 42.7 (3rd)
Opp Pts/G: 9.8 (1st)
SRS: 1st
SOS: 22nd

2002 Ohio State (14-0)
Pts/G: 29.3 (41st)
Opp Pts/G: 13.1 (2nd)
SRS: 5th
SOS: 21st

2004 USC (13-0)
Pts/G: 38.2 (6th)
Opp Pts/G: 13 (3rd)
SRS: 1st
SOS: 5th

2005 Texas (13-0)
Pts/G: 50.2 (1st)
Opp Pts/G: 16.4 (9th)
SRS: 1st
SOS: 23rd

2008 Florida (13-1)
Pts/G: 43.6 (4th)
Opp Pts/G: 12.9 (4th)
SRS: 1st
SOS: 5th

2009 Alabama (14-0)
Pts/G: 32.1 (22nd)
Opp Pts/G: 11.7 (2nd)
SRS: 1st
SOS: 2nd

2011 LSU (13-1)
Pts/G: 35.7 (17th)
Opp Pts/G: 11.3 (2nd)
SRS: 2nd
SOS: 8th

2013 Florida State (14-0)
Pts/G: 51.6 (2nd)
Opp Pts/G: 12.1 (1st)
SRS: 1st
SOS: 59th

2018 Clemson (15-0)
Pts/G: 44.3 (4th)
Opp Pts/G: 13.1 (1st)
SRS: 1st
SOS: 19th


2019 LSU (15-0)
Pts/G: 48.4 (1st)
Opp Pts/G: 21.9 (32nd)
SRS: 2nd
SOS: 6th

2020 Alabama (13-0) 'Covid'
Pts/G: 48.5 (2nd)
Opp Pts/G: 19.4 (13th)
SRS: 1st
SOS: 3rd

2021 Georgia (14-1)
Pts/G: 38.6 (9th)
Opp Pts/G: 10.2 (1st)
SRS: 1st
SOS: 8th

2022 Georgia (15-0)
Pts/G: 41.1 (5th)
Opp Pts/G: 14.3 (5th)
SRS: 1st
SOS: 11th
 
Let's be honest though, the teams from 2014 or later would trash most of the teams prior. The game has changed that much. If you look at it based on performance metrics, sure teams in the past stack-up but if you go off how "good" the team is from eye test, all my top 6 would be in 2014 or later. (Yes that includes the overrated, overhyped 2001 Miami team. I think 2004 USC could take them personally).
 
I know the 2022 UGA team went undefeated and the 2021 team didn’t, but 2021 was a better team. The 2022 team just avoided Bama all together
 
Volbound1700 said:
Let's be honest though, the teams from 2014 or later would trash most of the teams prior. The game has changed that much. If you look at it based on performance metrics, sure teams in the past stack-up but if you go off how "good" the team is from eye test, all my top 6 would be in 2014 or later. (Yes that includes the overrated, overhyped 2001 Miami team. I think 2004 USC could take them personally).
Click to expand...


Says the fraudster who voted for 1998 Tennessee. LMAO!!

1682086222600.png
 
Red_Alert said:
Says the fraudster who voted for 1998 Tennessee. LMAO!!

View attachment 100605
Click to expand...

I had to be homerish some :). Yeah any of the teams after 2014 would kill 1998 Tennessee. Heck, I think Tennessee this past season may be able to beat them. I also voted for 2004 USC.
 
Red_Alert said:
STFU, fraud.
Click to expand...

cry baby GIF
 
My point is to be fair, this should be split into a bracket of 1997-2010 and then a separate one for 2011-2022.

The two eras of CFB are just not comparable.

EDIT: If you are going to include teams prior to 2010, you might as well open the vote up to all of CFB. Heck, I imagine 1995 Nebraska would be very high on the rankings for example.
 
Red_Alert said:
And you're still lying.
Click to expand...

Read my post again. I said if I voted on "eye test". Based on past discussions, your reading comprehension isn't that good.

Then again, it is, you just want to troll people on irrelevant posts or grammar issues because you have the maturity of a 12-year old in your arguing skills.
 
Volbound1700 said:
My point is to be fair, this should be split into a bracket of 1997-2010 and then a separate one for 2011-2022.

The two eras of CFB are just not comparable.
Click to expand...

Then your votes should have been for 6 of the 7 teams that are 2011 and after.

You're still being disingenuous.
 
Volbound1700 said:
Let's be honest though, the teams from 2014 or later would trash most of the teams prior. The game has changed that much. If you look at it based on performance metrics, sure teams in the past stack-up but if you go off how "good" the team is from eye test, all my top 6 would be in 2014 or later. (Yes that includes the overrated, overhyped 2001 Miami team. I think 2004 USC could take them personally).
Click to expand...
I disagree. Coaching was insane in early 2000s. I don't think change really means improvement. It seems QBs had bigger names in early 2000s than they do now, and now is designed to make them bigger than ever.
 
Red_Alert said:
Then your votes should have been for 6 of the 7 teams that are 2011 and after.

You're still being disingenuous.
Click to expand...

Not really, I am arguing he should change the entire format. I stated before that the criteria is not defined on how to even grade the skill. This is why 1997 Michigan got some many votes. People are just picking teams based on favoritism so I did the same.
 
iowajerms said:
I disagree. Coaching was insane in early 2000s. I don't think change really means improvement. It seems QBs had bigger names in early 2000s than they do now, and now is designed to make them bigger than ever.
Click to expand...

The implementation of new offense never seen before starting in 2010 makes a big difference. Also, I don't see a coach in early 2000s that competes well against Dabo Swinney, Nick Saban, Kirby Smart, etc.

This is why I am not that high on 2001 Miami. Their coaching was mediocre (that is why Larry Coker got fired earlier) and their QB was serviceable. I think 2004 USC or 2006/2008 Florida were the best teams that decade.

Sure 2001 Miami had that rash of NFL picks but that was for two reasons:

1. It aligned where all the picks went that year instead of over multiple years like other teams
2. Miami did have the top overall NFL picks but that doesn't always translate into the BEST team

Take Tennessee under Fulmer for example. 2001 Tennessee had far more future NFL stars than 1998 Tennessee but it is clear the 1998 team was better overall from a team mentality.

BTW, if you go off season performance, 1995 Nebraska is the best team in the modern era based on their performance against their schedule. 1899 Sewanee deserves some love though :).

There were plenty of great Alabama, Oklahoma, Nebraska, Ohio State, Texas, Notre Dame, USC teams of past decades that would be interesting to stick on an all-time list.
 
"All my top 6 would be in 2014 or later." - volbound

"2011 to 2022 should be a separate poll" - volbound

Votes 1998 Tennessee. LMAO!!
 
@iowajerms to be fair, I am probably over complicated a fun off-season exercise...
 
Here is the bracket

Untitled2.jpg
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top