2024 Recruiting Thread

I'm actually sort of bullish on the DL recruits in the 22/23 class. They're obviously buried by upperclassmen/future NFL draft picks, but I love what we've got at edge, and there are some really nice pieces at DT as well, especially with Moore.

West and Scott will be Buckeyes most likely, West for sure. We're in great shape there as well from the past two classes so I'm not concerned. OL looks really solid as well, maybe add one more high end OT but that's about it. Frey is doing a great job cleaning up after dipshit Stud.

We look good for Jordan Seaton he's top 150 and the #6 Interior OL in the composite. Agreed that Frey is doing a nice job.

I agree we did still get some nice pieces on the DL last year but considering what it could had been it was disappointing. Definitely could be a lot worse though. You need elite DL to win big though. It seems like maybe we've lost our touch there and Johnson may be fading as a big time recruiter. But we will see how this year ends up shaking out. As things stand though at the moment it doesn't really seem like we are really seriously in on any of the upper end DL.
 
We look good for Jordan Seaton he's top 150 and the #6 Interior OL in the composite. Agreed that Frey is doing a nice job.

I agree we did still get some nice pieces on the DL last year but considering what it could had been it was disappointing. Definitely could be a lot worse though. You need elite DL to win big though. It seems like maybe we've lost our touch there and Johnson may be fading as a big time recruiter. But we will see how this year ends up shaking out. As things stand though at the moment it doesn't really seem like we are really seriously in on any of the upper end DL.
I'm ok with it at this point. The rankings are gonna reshuffle several more times before ESD so it doesn't really matter. Getting to the QB is important and we've been still bringing in big name Edge players every year.
 
I'm ok with it at this point. The rankings are gonna reshuffle several more times before ESD so it doesn't really matter. Getting to the QB is important and we've been still bringing in big name Edge players every year.

Hoping JTT and Sawyer both have big breakthrough years this year. That would be a big help for the secondary as well. Our pass rush has been pretty lackluster the past couple of years.
 
2024 is an interesting year for running back. Things are starting to fall in place.

It appeared that the Oklahoma Sooners were settled on their running back targets for the 2024 Recruiting Class. Names like Caden Durham, Tovani Mizell, and Xavier Robinson looked to be trending to the Sooners recently. That may be who the Sooners end up with, but they’re not leaving any stone unturned.

Over the weekend, the Oklahoma Sooners extended an offer to 2024 four-star running back Nathaniel Frazier. He was also named the Under Armour Next running back MVP with his performance at the all-star camp.

He’s a top 20 running back and a top 25 player in the state of California.

Frazier plays his high school ball with California powerhouse Mater Dei. In 2022, Frazier ran for 693 yards and eight touchdowns on just 61 carries. He averaged an incredible 11.4 yards per carry, according to Max Preps.

He’s an incredibly explosive player with legit track speed. He just put up a personal best in the 100 meters of 10.58. And that speed jumps off the screen. Frazier also displays fantastic contact balance. He’s strong and can bounce off would-be tacklers or make them miss altogether. But once he’s in the open field, Nathaniel Frazier isn’t getting caught. He’s an incredible athlete that shows off good vision and hits the hole fast, and can also beat defenders to the edge.

With his speed and big-play ability, it’s no wonder he has 20 Power Five offers to his ledger.
 
I hate to put any credence in these local SI sites, but this sounds good for my team:

Last week, Steve Wiltfong, 247Sports.com's Director of Recruiting, flipped his crystal ball prediction from USC to Georgia for Raiola.

Five days before that, USC head coach Lincoln Riley was asked about recruiting quarterbacks and he gave a detailed response that included: "If he’s scared to compete, this ain’t the room for him."

Riley also said that ideally he'd like to add high profile QB's in back-to-back classes.

"I'd love to do it," he said.


Not exactly a brilliant move by Riley, especially with his move to USC because he was scared to compete in the SEC. Kidding, kind of.

https://www.si.com/college/usc/recr...n-to-usc-picks-up-steam-as-dylan-raiola-fades
 
I hate to put any credence in these local SI sites, but this sounds good for my team:

Last week, Steve Wiltfong, 247Sports.com's Director of Recruiting, flipped his crystal ball prediction from USC to Georgia for Raiola.

Five days before that, USC head coach Lincoln Riley was asked about recruiting quarterbacks and he gave a detailed response that included: "If he’s scared to compete, this ain’t the room for him."

Riley also said that ideally he'd like to add high profile QB's in back-to-back classes.

"I'd love to do it," he said.


Not exactly a brilliant move by Riley, especially with his move to USC because he was scared to compete in the SEC. Kidding, kind of.

https://www.si.com/college/usc/recr...n-to-usc-picks-up-steam-as-dylan-raiola-fades
There is a lot of things you can criticize Riley for, but QB takes aren't one of them. I'm not sure how many more red flags you have to see to realize that Raiola is going to flake. tOSU now SC.. both schools who have HCs that have had successes with QBs have passed on him now because he wants to go to a place where he's walking in as QB1 day one? Ehh...
 
There is a lot of things you can criticize Riley for, but QB takes aren't one of them. I'm not sure how many more red flags you have to see to realize that Raiola is going to flake. tOSU now SC.. both schools who have HCs that have had successes with QBs have passed on him now because he wants to go to a place where he's walking in as QB1 day one? Ehh...
Dude, that's Riley being salty because he is losing out. He isn't passing on DR. And he knows for a fact that he has to compete if hecomes to UGA. You honestly think Smart told him he would be a day 1 starter? LOL.
 
Dude, that's Riley being salty because he is losing out. He isn't passing on DR. And he knows for a fact that he has to compete if hecomes to UGA. You honestly think Smart told him he would be a day 1 starter? LOL.
one day you will take off your bulldog shades and you will see what it actually is..

Kid transfers in high school twice, he commits to tosu (gets mad that they continue to recruit other QBs), decommits.. Then goes to 3 other visits (NU, UGA, SC).. all getting rave reviews.. Then it feels like SC has all the momentum til it doesn't once again. Day has come out and said the same thing Lincoln did, but it's sour grapes? The coach who shits out Heisman caliber QBs on the regular is now salty cause Raiola wants to go elsewhere? Was Day salty too?

I think Smart would tell him that he has every reason to think he could start day 1(because that's what helicopter dad wants).. which is why i predict that he does commit and enroll at UGA, but hits the portal the following Spring to Nebraska..
 
one day you will take off your bulldog shades and you will see what it actually is..

Kid transfers in high school twice, he commits to tosu (gets mad that they continue to recruit other QBs), decommits.. Then goes to 3 other visits (NU, UGA, SC).. all getting rave reviews.. Then it feels like SC has all the momentum til it doesn't once again. Day has come out and said the same thing Lincoln did, but it's sour grapes? The coach who shits out Heisman caliber QBs on the regular is now salty cause Raiola wants to go elsewhere? Was Day salty too?

I think Smart would tell him that he has every reason to think he could start day 1(because that's what helicopter dad wants).. which is why i predict that he does commit and enroll at UGA, but hits the portal the following Spring to Nebraska..
You clearly don't know anything about Smart if you think that. I mean Fields didn't play and left for tOSU.

What you wrote makes no sense ... if he comes to UGA because he has been promised to start, why would he transfer? Smart would never promise playing time ... we are known for 5*s having to wait for their turn. And 70% of QBs transfer anyway ... if he doesn't win the job after a year or two, I expect him to transfer.

Stop with the bulldog shades bullshit. Yes, I am biased toward UGA, but on this one, I have a clear head.

Yeah, Riley, in that interview, is salty as hell. What he said is idiotic. Smart would never call a kid out like that. He knows to keep relationships clean so that they might come back later.
 
You clearly don't know anything about Smart if you think that. I mean Fields didn't play and left for tOSU.

What you wrote makes no sense ... if he comes to UGA because he has been promised to start, why would he transfer? Smart would never promise playing time ... we are known for 5*s having to wait for their turn. And 70% of QBs transfer anyway ... if he doesn't win the job after a year or two, I expect him to transfer.

Stop with the bulldog shades bullshit. Yes, I am biased toward UGA, but on this one, I have a clear head.

Yeah, Riley, in that interview, is salty as hell. What he said is idiotic. Smart would never call a kid out like that. He knows to keep relationships clean so that they might come back later.
lol you always mentioned Fields.. as if that was a fair competition where he had an incumbent starter there... then had the incident with the baseball player.. Actually that's a good comparison.. cause I think Raiola bolts after a year too

But enjoy it, he will look terrific on paper when it comes to the recruiting class that should be #1 this cycle
 
lol you always mentioned Fields.. as if that was a fair competition where he had an incumbent starter there... then had the incident with the baseball player.. Actually that's a good comparison.. cause I think Raiola bolts after a year too

But enjoy it, he will look terrific on paper when it comes to the recruiting class that should be #1 this cycle
You really shouldn't act like you know anything about UGA football, because you don't. It's why I would never continue to argue with you about anything Texas ... your knowledge is greater than mine by a large factor.

1. My point is that Smart didn't promise that Fields would start, and he was the no. 1 recruit that year. He told him he had to compete, and he couldn't beat out Fromm. The idea that he would require Fields to compete but is now promising that Raiola gets immediate PT doesn't make sense.

2. Incumbent? Fromm had 1 year of experience (albeit a good year), and there were no other QBs in that room. Raiola is coming into a class where we already have the no. 144 player, QB12 who will move up a lot in the rankings, and we have three QBs with 3, 2, and 1 years experience already here (1 will leave by transfer), all of whom were 5* or 4*. He's coming into a loaded QB room - he will have a returning starter, and then a QB2 with 3 years of experience, and another QB in his class. Moreover, we don't start freshman QBs unless we have to ... Eason and Fromm as examples ... because our offense requires they know how to make pre-snap reads that a freshman won't know, no matter how physically talented they are.

3. The baseball incident was a nothingburger. The attorney, Tom Mars, used that to get immediate eligibility. A drunk baseball player yelled some stupid shit from the stands. If you think that is why Fields left, LOL. You, who doesn't follow UGA closely, are arguing with one who follows it too closely. So let me fill you in - the same year after the baseball player yelled that shit, Fields' sister enrolled at UGA with a softball scholarship. I am sure her parents were totally worried about the racism at UGA ... SMH.
 
You really shouldn't act like you know anything about UGA football, because you don't. It's why I would never continue to argue with you about anything Texas ... your knowledge is greater than mine by a large factor.

1. My point is that Smart didn't promise that Fields would start, and he was the no. 1 recruit that year. He told him he had to compete, and he couldn't beat out Fromm. The idea that he would require Fields to compete but is now promising that Raiola gets immediate PT doesn't make sense.

2. Incumbent? Fromm had 1 year of experience (albeit a good year), and there were no other QBs in that room. Raiola is coming into a class where we already have the no. 144 player, QB12 who will move up a lot in the rankings, and we have three QBs with 3, 2, and 1 years experience already here (1 will leave by transfer), all of whom were 5* or 4*. He's coming into a loaded QB room - he will have a returning starter, and then a QB2 with 3 years of experience, and another QB in his class. Moreover, we don't start freshman QBs unless we have to ... Eason and Fromm as examples ... because our offense requires they know how to make pre-snap reads that a freshman won't know, no matter how physically talented they are.

3. The baseball incident was a nothingburger. The attorney, Tom Mars, used that to get immediate eligibility. A drunk baseball player yelled some stupid shit from the stands. If you think that is why Fields left, LOL. You, who doesn't follow UGA closely, are arguing with one who follows it too closely. So let me fill you in - the same year after the baseball player yelled that shit, Fields' sister enrolled at UGA with a softball scholarship. I am sure her parents were totally worried about the racism at UGA ... SMH.
It would have been hard to bench Fromm after you guys had just gone to a NCG with him, but it was a major mistake to start him over Fields in 2018. You would've had 3 years of Fields, who was unquestionably elite at the college level while Fromm was solid but not special. Fields would have taken your offense to another level that Fromm simply couldn't. Big swing and a miss on Kirby's part.
 
It would have been hard to bench Fromm after you guys had just gone to a NCG with him, but it was a major mistake to start him over Fields in 2018. You would've had 3 years of Fields, who was unquestionably elite at the college level while Fromm was solid but not special. Fields would have taken your offense to another level that Fromm simply couldn't. Big swing and a miss on Kirby's part.
There is no way that you could sit Fromm and start a freshman Fields in 2018. No coach would have done that. You have to realize the last time Fromm came off the field in the 2017 season, he had UGA up in OT in the NC game. The D lost that natty, not Fromm.

And then he was good in 2018 except the USCjr game. We were Jalen Hurts pulling the game out of his ass in the SECCG away from being in the CFP again. In the SECCG, Fromm was 25 of 39 for 301 yards, 7.7 ypp, 3 TDs, 0 INT and a QBR of 94.8.

He was better than solid, even if he didn't have the talent that Fields had. It really was a no win situation for Smart. Knowing what he knew at the time, and without the luxury of looking back, he'd do the same thing and it would have been the right choice. There were also some locker room issues, and his dad did him no favors at UGA. Let's just say that Pablo isn't well-liked at UGA.

You also have to understand that Fields was not good as a Freshman. He had a chance to take the job and didn't. The same problems he has in Chicago, he had at UGA. He's a one read guy. It worked well at tOSU, but it wasn't going to work at UGA.
 
There is no way that you could sit Fromm and start a freshman Fields in 2018. No coach would have done that. You have to realize the last time Fromm came off the field in the 2017 season, he had UGA up in OT in the NC game. The D lost that natty, not Fromm.

And then he was good in 2018 except the USCjr game. We were Jalen Hurts pulling the game out of his ass in the SECCG away from being in the CFP again. In the SECCG, Fromm was 25 of 39 for 301 yards, 7.7 ypp, 3 TDs, 0 INT and a QBR of 94.8.

He was better than solid, even if he didn't have the talent that Fields had. It really was a no win situation for Smart. Knowing what he knew at the time, and without the luxury of looking back, he'd do the same thing and it would have been the right choice. There were also some locker room issues, and his dad did him no favors at UGA. Let's just say that Pablo isn't well-liked at UGA.

You also have to understand that Fields was not good as a Freshman. He had a chance to take the job and didn't. The same problems he has in Chicago, he had at UGA. He's a one read guy. It worked well at tOSU, but it wasn't going to work at UGA.
I strongly, strongly doubt there was an actual "competition" when Fields was a freshman, and you pretty much verified that with your very first sentence above.

Secondly, any shortcomings Fields had at UGA were squarely on the coaches, because he was immediately a monster at OSU, though I'm not sure how you look at his limited stats at UGA and see a "bad" QB. Also, to act like the issues in Chicago are comparable to anything in college is ignorant. There isn't a QB in the NFL that would have been successful in Chicago last year. Not to say Fields doesn't have room for improvement, he certainly does, but when you have a brand new, first time HC/OC, a dogshit OL, a RB who is averaging 4 ypc, and Darnell Mooney operating as your top receiving weapon, nobody is gonna look good.
 
I strongly, strongly doubt there was an actual "competition" when Fields was a freshman, and you pretty much verified that with your very first sentence above.

Secondly, any shortcomings Fields had at UGA were squarely on the coaches, because he was immediately a monster at OSU, though I'm not sure how you look at his limited stats at UGA and see a "bad" QB. Also, to act like the issues in Chicago are comparable to anything in college is ignorant. There isn't a QB in the NFL that would have been successful in Chicago last year. Not to say Fields doesn't have room for improvement, he certainly does, but when you have a brand new, first time HC/OC, a dogshit OL, a RB who is averaging 4 ypc, and Darnell Mooney operating as your top receiving weapon, nobody is gonna look good.
UGA hasn't had the type of offense in a long time where a freshman QB can really step in. Fromm and Eason did it because they had to, they dummied down the playbook, and they had really good RBs to rely on (Gurley, Chubb, Michel, and Swift).

There was absolutely a competition. Fromm won it. That shouldn't be a surprise. Fromm had 14 games under his belt and for his first two years he was a damn good QB. As a true freshman he was 11th in QBR. In his second year, the year you say Fields should have replaced him, he was 5th in QBR.
 
UGA hasn't had the type of offense in a long time where a freshman QB can really step in. Fromm and Eason did it because they had to, they dummied down the playbook, and they had really good RBs to rely on (Gurley, Chubb, Michel, and Swift).

There was absolutely a competition. Fromm won it. That shouldn't be a surprise. Fromm had 14 games under his belt and for his first two years he was a damn good QB. As a true freshman he was 11th in QBR. In his second year, the year you say Fields should have replaced him, he was 5th in QBR.
I'd say if Fromm and Eason could step in and do it, Fields easily could have. The talent was there for them to have a much more explosive offense, which I think could have been realized with Fields. His numbers as a passer his first full year as a starter at OSU just dwarfed Fromm's from 2018, and on not that many more attempts. Couple that with the fact he added an additional 484 yards and 10 TDs on the ground, compared to -27 yards and 0 TDs from Fromm in 2018, and it is hard to really defend the decision.
 
I'd say if Fromm and Eason could step in and do it, Fields easily could have. The talent was there for them to have a much more explosive offense, which I think could have been realized with Fields. His numbers as a passer his first full year as a starter at OSU just dwarfed Fromm's from 2018, and on not that many more attempts. Couple that with the fact he added an additional 484 yards and 10 TDs on the ground, compared to -27 yards and 0 TDs from Fromm in 2018, and it is hard to really defend the decision.
You are comparing two totally different offenses. UGA 2018 and tOSU 2018 couldn't have been more different. It's why Fields was actually a better fit for tOSU than UGA.

Look, UGA updated their offense in 2020-2023. They weren't going to do that in 2018. Criticize Smart for that if you want. But starting Fromm over Fields was a no-brainer. We would have lost 2-3 games with Fields as a freshman.
 
You are comparing two totally different offenses. UGA 2018 and tOSU 2018 couldn't have been more different. It's why Fields was actually a better fit for tOSU than UGA.

Look, UGA updated their offense in 2020-2023. They weren't going to do that in 2018. Criticize Smart for that if you want. But starting Fromm over Fields was a no-brainer. We would have lost 2-3 games with Fields as a freshman.
Fields didn't throw too many more passes in 2019 than Fromm did in 18 though, and again, the running stats also make a huge difference. He clearly had those same running abilities when he was at UGA and it's a dimension they didn't have in the slightest bit with Fromm. Also, you did lose 3 games when Fields was a freshman, so why not give him a shot? It didn't take a genius to see who the more talented guy was, regardless of how 2017 went (their offense was incredible despite him being just alright, which will happen when you have Nick Chubb, D'Andre Swift, and Sony Michel in the same backfield).
 
Back
Top