Starting pitching has actually been kind of wishy washy this year.
Bieber has been good.
McKenzie & Quantrill are good but they are inconsistent at times, especially McKenzie
and the #4 and #5 has been a circle jerk mess. Civale has a ERA in the 5s. I guess he's been "better" since getting off the IL though (it was in the 7s). Plesac has been hurt for like a month but was mediocre (4.39 ERA)
There's been a lot of bullpen games and AAA guys filling those slots.
The position players have been surprisingly good. Jose Ramirez has had another superstar year but he may not even be their MVP (Andres Gimenez has been amazing), plus Kwan looks like Brett Butler 2.0 and Andres Gimenez is a solid shortstop. Even with Straw's lousy offensive numbers he's still managed to be a ~2 WAR player on his baserunning and defense. Naylor's shown as improvement as well, though he needs to cut down on the ground balls. Oscar Gonzalez also had a solid rookie year.