Poll Which Former Bama QB Would You Want If You HAD To Choose?

[Wild Turkey]

We had this argument at lunch yesterday so I thought it might be interesting to throw out there.

 

[tabascojet]

Anyone who votes jones is a Boston homer....

 

[Illustrious Potentate]

Won’t let me change my vote. My initial thought was Tua, but with his injury history I think I’d go with Hurts for the running threat and durability

 

[HammerDown]

I don't see Freddie Kitchens in the poll options. Where is Freddie Kitchens in the poll options?

 

[rsw626]

Namath or Stabler

 

[tabascojet]

Is McCarron even in the league anymore?

 

[Knight&Day]

Toss-up between AJ and Big Mac imo. Went with AJ.

 

[tabascojet]

Toss-up between AJ and Big Mac imo. Went with AJ.

Its a poll for the best qb not whose mom has the biggest tits...

 

[Kburjr]

Namath or Stabler

Starr

 

[PeoplesChicken]

Jay Barker or GTFO

 

[Guy Incognito]

Is McCarron even in the league anymore?

He almost was back, but lost a competition to Kurt Benkert (???) to be Garpopodopolous's backup in SF.

 

[Illustrious Potentate]

Brodie Croyle

 

[RP-29]

Starr

Yes, this is the correct answer.

 

[Illustrious Potentate]

Yes, this is the correct answer.

He’s like 90 if he’s still alive. He would be terrible right now

 

[Kachina]

I voted Mac.

With all the years I've watched Bama, Mac was definitely the most accurate and did something the others couldn't, lead Alabama to an undefeated season.

Jalen and Tua were incredible, and both will forever remain in Alabama lore, but Mac was more accurate, didn't ever seem to be flustered when things didn't go his way, and just had a way about him that made other teams either bring the house and try and pressure him, or get lit up.

Jalen was great because he didn't complain after losing his starting job.

Tua was great as he was probably the most talented, and had the greatest moment out of the 3, but he was injury prone and sometimes struggled on those deep balls.

AJ was a rock star, and the first during my watching life at Alabama. I'll always remember when bama beat ND, and him and Barrett Jones started arguing about the snap count despite being up already. It was the first time I saw a different perspective at Alabama, a culture of perfection.

 

[RP-29]

He’s like 90 if he’s still alive. He would be terrible right now

He passed away recently. And he's still the best Bama Q.

Besides that, thread title, the poll and the OP never stated "right now".

 

[Kachina]

He passed away recently. And he's still best Bama Q.

Besides that, thread title, the poll and the OP never stated "right now".

I figured it was assumed since all choices are younger guys.

 

[Illustrious Potentate]

He passed away recently. And he's still the best Bama Q.

Besides that, thread title, the poll and the OP never stated "right now".

Even if all time l, I’d stick with one that played after the forward pass was a key part of the game and leather helmets were out the window

 

[Kburjr]

I figured it was assumed since all choices are younger guys.

Recency bias.

 

[RP-29]

Even if all time l, I’d stick with one that played after the forward pass was a key part of the game and leather helmets were out the window

You need to brush up on your NFL history, bruh. Starr played when men played football.