- Joined
- Aug 19, 2020
- Posts
- 552
- Reaction score
- 276
- Bookie:
- $ 1,000.00




Bloodmoon. It was set about ten thousand years before the original Game of Thrones.
Something I've said before: I am so glad they decided to proceed with House of the Dragon instead of Bloodmoon. The problem with Bloodmoon is that it's not based on any actual George R. R. Martin book, but instead just on scattered references throughout the books to myths of the Long Night, so we would have ended up with the same shitty fanfiction from TV writers that season 8 was.
At least with House of the Dragon, we get a story based on an actual George R. R. Martin book, even if the details of the story in that book are rather sparse (due to the book being a historical reference that covers over a century rather than in-depth novels covering a few years the way the main aSoIaF series is).
I wouldn't have a problem with a good show runner doing something from this universe that is largely based on their own story telling.
IMO, Benioff and Weiss had 2 major problems, or maybe even 3 depend on how you look at it.
1. George Martin had initially committed to finishing the books before the show. In retrospect this was pure folly. So this put them in a bit of a lerch in that, while they knew the end of the story, they did NOT know how the subplots played out. So they kinda had to fill in the blanks. That was ALWAYS going to be tricky to do and this led to them not giving those subplots enough attention.
2. B&W had signed on to do a Star Wars movie and a new HBO series. They wanted to get started with those so they just rushed the ending. And they rushed it for no reason because both the new Star Wars movies and the new HBO show were shelved.
3. No matter what they did, a lot of fans were NEVER going to like how that story ended.
I don't think that means that other writers, freed from some of the expectations couldn't do some really interesting work within this universe.